Tuesday, December 30, 2025

A Grease-Dry Wheel Greatly Needing to Shriek—Not Just Squeak

With every designated mental health or illness awareness month or week, various mainstream media (news, social and entertainment) will platitudinously state or promote the obvious: that society, collectively and as individuals, must open up its/our minds and encourage common dialogue toward far more fruitfully treating and preventing mental illness.

Needless to say, everyone will agree, at least publicly, that stigmatizing such illness and, by extension, its bearers should have ceased long ago.

But then that’s basically as far as it goes.

Unlike with the loud and apparently quite effective voices lobbying the news, social and entertainment media against reinforcing stereotypes based on skin color, sexuality, gender and even gender bending, there's no comparable influential protest voice against reinforcing stereotypes based on mental illness. It's sometimes referred to as the squeaky-wheel effect.

When it comes to irresponsibly stereotyping and/or stigmatizing people specifically living with schizophrenia, the 2008 box-office-hit movie The Dark Knight (as overall entertaining as it was) could be a textbook example.

In one shameful scene, the glorified Batman character recklessly erroneously grumbles to the district attorney character Harvey Dent that the sinisterly-sneering clearly-conscience-lacking murderer he has handcuffed to a wheeled stretcher is “a paranoid schizophrenic — exactly the kind of mind that the Joker attracts.”

From what I recall, Tim Burton’s Batman movies managed to not gratuitously stigmatize the mentally ill or their affliction.

[I should add here, however, that I rather enjoyed and appreciated the relatively sympathetic theme on poverty and especially mental illness in the 2019 film Joker.]

Like The Dark Knight, the 2021 horror-flick Old also stigmatizes schizophrenia via a creepy character’s violent behavior.

We had entered the third millennium, yet a 4/4-star-rated Hollywood hit movie as well as a much more recent film, could still be readily found flagrantly demonizing characters based on their mental illness.

There was no societal or vocal condemnation. It seemed to not matter that people living with schizophrenia are generally more likely to harm themselves and/or be a victim of violence than they are to harm others.

No comments:

Post a Comment