JODIE COMER TOLD TO STOP COMFORTING CRYING NEWBORNS MAKING HER NEW FILM
By Celebretainment Jan 8, 2024
Jodie Comer was ordered to stop soothing crying babies
during the making of her new film.
The 30-year-old ‘Killing Eve’ actress, who has no
children, plays a petrified mum who flees her London home with her newborn amid
an ecological flooding disaster in the upcoming survival movie ‘The End We
Start From’.
She told The Sunday Times about the experience of
handling different babies during its production: “It’s such a lesson. The
smallest baby was eight weeks. At first my hands were visibly shaking. My
younger cousins have grown up now, so I’m not around babies an awful lot.
“It felt like a huge responsibility. I thought, ‘Wow,
they’re so fragile’.”
Jodie added she became more confident with the babies on
set and would try to calm the children during shooting — but was told to let
them cry.
She said: “I became more comfortable, sometimes to my
detriment! There are scenes where we needed a baby to cry but I was soothing
him instead.
“The crew would shout, ‘Stop!’ ….
________
In his
book The
Interpretation of Dreams, Dr. Sigmund Freud states: “It is painful to me to think that
many of the hypotheses upon which I base my psychological solution of the
psychoneuroses will arouse skepticism and ridicule when they first become
known.
“For instance, I shall have to assert that impressions
of the second year of life, and even the first, leave an enduring trace upon
the emotional life of subsequent neuropaths [i.e. neurotic persons], and that
these impressions — although greatly distorted and exaggerated by the memory —
may furnish the earliest and profoundest basis of a hysterical [i.e. neurotic]
symptom …
“[I]t is my well-founded conviction that both doctrines
[i.e. theories] are true. In confirmation of this I recall certain examples in
which the death of the father occurred when the child was very young, and
subsequent incidents, otherwise inexplicable, proved that the child had
unconsciously preserved recollections of the person who had so early gone out
of its life.”
Contemporary research tells us that, since it cannot
fight or flight, a baby stuck in a crib on its back hearing parental discord in
the next room can only “move
into a third neurological state, known as a ‘freeze’ state … This freeze state
is a trauma state” (Childhood Disrupted: How Your Biography Becomes Your
Biology and How You Can Heal, pg.123).
This causes its brain to improperly develop; and if
allowed to continue, it’s the helpless infant’s starting point towards a
childhood, adolescence and (in particular) adulthood in which its brain
uncontrollably releases potentially damaging levels of inflammation-promoting
stress hormones and chemicals, even in non-stressful daily routines.
We also now know that it’s the unpredictability of a
stressor, and not the intensity, that does the most harm. When the
stressor “is
completely predictable, even if it is more traumatic — such as giving a
[laboratory] rat a regularly scheduled foot shock accompanied by a sharp, loud
sound — the stress does not create these exact same [negative] brain changes.”
(pg. 42)
Decades before reading Freud’s theories or any others
regarding very early life trauma, I began cringing at how producers and
directors of negatively melodramatic scenes — let alone the willing parents of
the undoubtedly extremely upset infants and toddlers used—can comfortably
conclude that no psychological harm would come to their infant/toddler actors,
regardless of their screaming in bewilderment. (And they’re not really actors
since they are not cognizant of their fictional environment.)
Initially I’d presumed there was an educated general
consensus within the entertainment industry on this matter, perhaps even on the
advice of mental health and/or psychology academia, otherwise the practice
would logically compassionately cease. But I became increasingly doubtful of
the factual accuracy of any such potential consensus.
Cannot one logically conclude by observing their
turmoil-filled facial expressions that they’re perceiving, and likely
cerebrally recording, the hyper-emotional scene activity around them at face
value rather than as a fictitious occurrence?
I could understand the practice commonly occurring
within a naïve entertainment industry of the 20th Century, but I’m still seeing
it in contemporary small and big screen movie productions. [Over the last five
years or so, I’ve unsuccessfully tried contacting various actor unions on this
matter.]
One example that readily comes to my mind is the
movie Hustlers (with
actress Jennifer Lopez), in which a toddler is clearly genuinely distraught; it
wails while caught in between a screaming match between mother (“Destiny”) and
father characters.
An older example is in the 2008 movie Pride and Glory, where
actor Colin Farrell’s crooked-cop character holds a screaming baby while
threatening to hot-iron its face if he doesn’t get the information he wants
from the infant’s gangster father. There’s hyper-dramatic screaming by all the
characters, of course, but not all are aware it’s just acting.
And let’s not overlook the melodramatic scene in Harry Potter and the Deathly
Hallows Part 2 in which a rocking Severus Snape wails over a
dead Lily Potter in his arms, as the Harry-Potter-as-an-infant ‘actor’ also
cries at what he perceives as genuine heartbreaking-loss mourning. …
Meanwhile, in January of 2017, a Vancouver dog-rescue
organization cancelled a scheduled fundraiser preceding the big release of the
then-new film A
Dog’s Purpose, according to a Vancouver Sun story, after “the German shepherd star of the
film was put under duress during one scene.”
The founder of Thank Dog I Am Out (Dog Rescue
Society), Susan Paterson, was quoted as saying, “We are shocked and disappointed by
what we have seen, and we cannot in good conscience continue with our
pre-screening of the movie.”
... This incident managed to create a
controversy for the ensuing news week.
While animal cruelty by the industry shouldn’t be
tolerated, there should be even less allowance for using unaware infants and
toddlers in negatively hyper-emotional drama — especially when contemporary
alternatives can readily be utilized (e.g. a mannequin infant or digital
manipulation tech).
No comments:
Post a Comment